Monroe County real estate: House on Starfish Lane sells for $945,000

Published Jun 19, 2025

A 1,265-square-foot house built in 1991 has changed hands. The property located at 17182 Starfish Lane in Sugarloaf Key was sold on May 21, 2025. The $945,000 purchase price works out to $747 per square foot. This single-story home has two bedrooms. The lot of the property covers a substantial area of 0.3 acres.

Additional houses that have recently been purchased close by include:

· A 2,517-square-foot home at 17178 Bonefish Lane in Summerland Key sold in December 2022 for $2,350,000, a price per square foot of $934. The home has 4 bedrooms.

· In October 2021, a 960-square-foot home on Green Turtle Lane in Summerland Key sold for $965,000, a price per square foot of $1,005. The home has 1 bedroom.

· On Wahoo Lane, Summerland Key, in November 2024, a 1,600-square-foot home was sold for $1,200,000, a price per square foot of $750. The home has 2 bedrooms.