Key Largo property sale: Condominium sells for $4.4 million

Published Oct 17, 2025

The property at 17 Pumpkin Cay Road #B in Key Largo was sold on Sept. 18, 2025 for $4,400,000 which represents a price per square foot of $3,279. The condominium, built in 1973, has an interior space of 1,342 square feet. The layout of this apartment includes two bedrooms and two bathrooms. The unit encompasses a generous 4.8 acres of land.

These nearby units have also recently been purchased:

· A 1,544-square-foot unit at 12 Marlin Lane in Key Largo sold in May 2022 for $2,495,000, a price per square foot of $1,616. The unit has 2 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms.

· In June 2025, a 618-square-foot unit at 74B Anchor Drive #74B in Key Largo sold for $1,950,000, a price per square foot of $3,155. The unit has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom.

· At 72A Anchor Drive #72-A in Key Largo in September 2021, a 618-square-foot unit was sold for $950,000, a price per square foot of $1,537. The unit has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom.