How much were the top nine most expensive home sales in Herkimer County, reported last week?

Published Oct 6, 2025

A house in Old Forge that sold for $1.3 million tops the list of the most expensive residential real estate sales in Herkimer County in the past week.

In total, 11 residential real estate sales were recorded in the county during the past week, with an average price of $212,250, or $167 per square foot.

The prices in the list below include real estate sales where the title was recorded during the week of Sept. 29 even if the property may have been sold earlier.

9. $2,150, farmhouse at 504 Old State Road

A 1,695-square-foot farmhouse at 504 Old State Road in Poland, has been sold. The total purchase price was $2,150, $1 per square foot. The house was built in 1880. The house features 3 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 8.

Read more

8. $2,250, detached house at 677 North Gage Road

A single-family residence at 677 North Gage Road in Poland, has been sold. The price was $2,250. The house was built in 2013 and has a living area of 1,258 square feet. The price per square foot was $2. The house features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 8.

Read more

7. $6,500, single-family house at 114 Sulphur Springs Road

The single-family home at 114 Sulphur Springs Road in Newport, has been sold. The price was $6,500. The house was built in 1958. The house features 1 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 5.

Read more

6. $18K, single-family residence at 1695 Castle Road

The property at 1695 Castle Road in Newport has new owners. The price was $18,000. The single-family house was built in 1969. The deal was finalized on Sep. 5.

Read more

Bridge Street

5. $55K, triplex at 16 Bridge Street

A 3,358-square-foot triplex at 16 Bridge Street in Middleville has been sold. The price was $55,000, $16 per square foot. The house was built in 1900. The house features 9 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 5.

Read more

North Bellinger Street

4. $103K, single-family home at 418 North Bellinger Street

A sale has been finalized for a detached house at 418 North Bellinger Street in Herkimer. The price was $102,500. The house was built in 1900 and the living area totals 1,840 square feet. The price per square foot ended up at $56. The house features 4 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 5.

Read more

3. $343K, single-family residence at 142 Lakeview Ave.

The single-family residence at 142 Lakeview Ave. in Eagle Bay has new owners. The price was $343,000. The house was built in 1960 and has a living area of 1,536 square feet. The price per square foot was $223. The house features 4 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 5.

Read more

2. $500K, townhouse at 656 Hollywood Road

The sale of the townhouse at 656 Hollywood Road in Old Forge has been finalized. The price was $500,000. It was built in 1929 and has a living area of 1,016 square feet. The price per square foot was $492. The house features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 8.

Read more

1. $1.3 million, vacation residence at 150 Cold Springs Rd Spur

The property at 150 Cold Springs Rd Spur in Old Forge has new owners. The price was $1,250,000. The vacation residence was built in 1890 and has a living area of 1,440 square feet. The price per square foot was $868. The house features 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Sep. 8.

Read more