How much were the top 10 most expensive home sales in Herkimer County, reported last week?

Published Dec 15, 2025

A house in Old Forge that sold for $515,000 tops the list of the most expensive residential real estate sales in Herkimer County in the past week.

During the past week, a total of 35 residential real estate sales were registered in the county, with an average price of $170,988. The average price per square foot was $108.

The prices in the list below include real estate sales where the title was recorded during the week of Dec. 8 even if the property may have been sold earlier.

Stewart Street

10. $210K, detached house at 24 Stewart Street

A sale has been finalized for a single-family house at 24 Stewart Street in Dolgeville. The price was $210,000. The house was built in 1960 and the living area totals 1,454 square feet. The price per square foot ended up at $144. The house features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 10.

Read more

Silverstone Road

9. $210K, vacation residence at 216 Silverstone Road

A sale has been finalized for the vacation residence at 216 Silverstone Road in Remsen. The price was $210,000. It was built in 1970. The house features 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom. The deal was finalized on Nov. 7.

Read more

8. $210K, vacation residence at 103 Twitchell Inn Road

The sale of the vacation residence at 103 Twitchell Inn Road in Eagle Bay has been finalized. The price was $210,000. It was built in 1910. The house features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The deal was finalized on Nov. 12.

Read more

West Street

7. $214K, single-family home at 308 West Street

The single-family residence at 308 West Street in Herkimer has new owners. The price was $214,000. The house was built in 1953 and has a living area of 1,324 square feet. The price per square foot was $162. The house features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 7.

Read more

6. $250K, single-family home at 1946 State Route 51

The property at 1946 State Route 51 in Ilion has new owners. The price was $250,000. The single-family house was built in 1850 and has a living area of 1,767 square feet. The price per square foot was $141. The house features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 10.

Read more

5. $280K, single-family residence at 849 Lower Paradise Road

A 1,976-square-foot detached house at 849 Lower Paradise Road in Little Falls has been sold. The price was $280,000, $142 per square foot. The house was built in 1830. The house features 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The deal was finalized on Nov. 3.

Read more

Jerusalem Hill Road

4. $325K, single-family residence at 543 Jerusalem Hill Road

A 2,231-square-foot detached house at 543 Jerusalem Hill Road in Clayville, has been sold. The total purchase price was $325,000, $146 per square foot. The house was built in 1993. The house features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 7.

Read more

3. $354K, farmhouse at 1080 Steuben Hill Road

A farmhouse at 1080 Steuben Hill Road in Herkimer, has been sold. The price was $354,000. The house was built in 1997 and has a living area of 1,536 square feet. The price per square foot was $230. The house features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 7.

Read more

Military Road

2. $442K, vacation residence at 3279 Military Road

The sale of the vacation residence at 3279 Military Road in Newport has been finalized. The price was $442,000. It was built in 1830 and has a living area of 2,384 square feet. The price per square foot was $185. The house features 4 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The deal was finalized on Nov. 12.

Read more

1. $515K, single-family home at 160 Pawnee Drive

A 1,436-square-foot single-family house at 160 Pawnee Drive in Old Forge, has been sold. The total purchase price was $515,000, $359 per square foot. The house was built in 2004. The house features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The deal was finalized on Nov. 10.

Read more