The spacious historic unit at 12 Chestnut Street in New York Mills was sold on Sept. 15, 2025 for $225,000 which works out to $82 per square foot. The two-unit house, built in 1899, has an interior space of 2,754 square feet. This three-story duplex presents a total of five bedrooms and two bathrooms. Inside, there is one fireplace. In addition, the house features a detached two-car garage, providing ample room for vehicles and storage needs. The lot of the property is substantial, measuring 9,520 square feet.

Other houses have recently changed hands nearby:

· In May 2025, a 3,146-square-foot home at 551 Main Street #553 in New York Mills sold for $265,000, a price per square foot of $84. The home has 6 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.

· At 42 Floyd Street in New York Mills in December 2024, a 1,472-square-foot home was sold for $40,000, a price per square foot of $27. The home has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.

· A 1,512-square-foot home at 6 Saint Stanislaus Street in New York Mills sold in January 2025 for $212,000, a price per square foot of $140. The home has 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.